Opens in a new tab
Public Categories

‘Of Puppy Dog Tails, Sugar and Spice’: Gender Inequality and Discrimination in ECE

Search Entire Website
child climbs tree with teacher at early childhood centre

Of Puppy Dog Tails – Article published in the journal Delta 49(2), pp. 405-416, 1997.

This paper reviews how equal the opportunities for men in early childhood teaching are.

Men are scarce in the profession. Early childhood teaching is a women’s occupation. Given that men are under-represented and that the profession is dominated by women, could it be that men experience discrimination? The findings reported in this paper suggest that they do. The subjective experiences and perspectives of male childcare and kindergarten teachers and their female colleagues tell a story of apathy towards encouraging male participation in teaching, sexist treatment, and discriminatory employment practices. 

So what suggestions arise from the findings?  To achieve a more equitable balance of male and female teachers in early childhood centres two major suggestions arise from the findings.

1. Specific projects to recruit men both into training programmes and into employment are needed, as are a set of guidelines for employers on the appointment of men and gender-equity in the work­place.

2. There needs to be recognition that the child abuse argument is being used to keep men out of teaching and to limit their involvement with children. Positive action for change should be taken by all groups and organisations associated with early childhood education (including the Ministry of Education and the teachers’ union NZEI).

A focus on increasing the involvement of men in caring for and educating young children is needed.

To read go to: Of Puppy Dog Tails, sugar and Spice: Gender Inequality & Discrimination

Has this been useful?  Give us your feedback.

You are welcome to add a link to this page on your website. Copyright belongs to the OECE so please do not copy any content without our written permission.

Information provided is of a general nature. It is provided ‘as is’, and we accept no liability for its accuracy or completeness. See our Terms and Conditions.

Related Posts

men teaching

Men Who Teach Young Children NZ – Dr Sarah Alexander Speech

Men Who Teach Young Children NZ. ECE Symposium. Wellington, 15 August 2016 * Before giving some background to the main issues and challenges that lie…
Early Childhood Qualified teacher supporting infant feeding with baby bottle.

National Report: Time to Involve Men in Early Childhood Teaching – are Men Wanted and What Contributions Can They Make?

Time to Involve Men in Early Childhood Teaching The Findings of a National Survey. Report Published 2012. Prepared by Dr Sarah Alexander. Alexander, S. (2012)…
Dr Sarah Alexander at Men In ECE International Conference Berlin

NZ Represented at International Men in Early Childhood Education Event

There was NZ representation at the International Conference "Men in Early Childhood Education and Care" held in Berlin in September 2012.  Dr Sarah Alexander represented…
Men changing nappies. Nappy change table for infants at early childhood centre

Men Changing Nappies in ECE: Safety, Rights, and Best Practice

This article explains why male teachers must be able to carry out all caregiving tasks, including nappy changing, and sets out how men can respond…
early childhood teacher with infants

“A Few Good Men or a Few Too Many?”

The Original Massey University Research Study of Male Teachers (1997) "A Few Good Men or a Few Too Many? A study of Male Teachers" by…
what kind of teaching style do you adopt with young children?

Men in Childcare and Early Childhood Teaching: Why Male Teachers Matter

Why children need male teachers, how gender identity shapes their learning, what the research shows, and how services can address discrimination or parent concerns. It…
Joshua McKay, NZ

How to Achieve 8% Male Early Childhood Teachers – The Example of Norway

Male Teacher Target in Norway. By Dr Sarah Alexander. April 21, 2013. In Norway children aged 1 - 6 years attend the same institution (not…
boys play friends achievement

Proceedings of the First Men in Early Childhood Teaching Summit in NZ

Below is an outline of the Contents of the published proceedings of the very first Men in Early Childhood Teaching Summit in New Zealand, called…
male early childhood teachers and teacher supply in NZ

Proceedings of the 8th National Summit on Men in Early Childhood Teaching and Care

EC-Menz Summit Theme:  “Lifting the Lid on Gender Issues in Early Childhood Education” Held 7th-8th March, 2014. Wellington City, New Zealand. Conference Mihi Whakatau /…
male students stood behind this board to have their picture taken for voting on Facebook for the best male diversity model for ECE

A Successful Campaign to Get More Men into ECE

Campaign to Get Men To Take Up Early Childhood Work. By Dr Sarah Alexander. February 27, 2013. As money was available for use on gender…
The Office of ECE

Share This Information

Press Enter to see every result.
Public Area Categories
  • Categories

The Office of ECE Login

Take Action!

Help spread this vital ECE information, join our free social and email groups and become a member of OECE.

pay parity funding policy

1. Share This Information

2. Follow Our Social Pages

3. Get Regular Updates

Sign up to our free newsletters.

4. Become a Member

Membership Options