The Production of ‘Worthwhile’ Knowledge about Quality in Early Years Education

Search in Research
children writing drawing homebased

There has been substantial study of the quality of early years education yet only recently have researchers started to ask questions and take approaches that have some relevance and meaning for practice in early childhood programmes.

This paper reviews the ways in which research has shaped our perception of quality in early childhood education and associated limitations. The dominant approach to quality is then explained and some additional comparatively new approaches are identified. 

At present there is confusion as to what “quality” means due to the emergence of the stakeholder approach in the early 1990s and a more recent postmodernist interpretation (Dahlberg, Moss & Pence, 1999). To overcome this, and to increase specificity and relevance, it is suggested that we should look to the different dimensions of the word “quality” instead of regarding quality as a global, one-word-fits-all construct.

There are (at least) three different, distinct dimensions of quality in the early childhood field, namely:  “standards”, “organisational culture/excellence”, and “client benefits”.

The paper provided below on Knowledge about Quality, includes a useful diagram that shows different paths for quality promotion and assurance – and the consequences of each path.

You may like also like to read “Constructions of Quality in Early Childhood Centres

Already a Research Subscriber?
Reasons to Subscribe
Tertiary education libraries and individuals.

Enjoy online access to full copies of the latest issues of the NZ-International Research in ECE journal and more than 25 years of past issues of peer-reviewed published articles.

You will also have access to the NZ Doctoral thesis (Ph.D, and Ed.D) and the NZ Master’s thesis directory of theses relevant to early childhood education and care.

For those who are new to doing research, thesis supervisors, and conference paper selectors, we have a range of articles to inform and support you.  These include a guide to ethics when doing, writing, and disseminating research; reviewing abstracts and conference submissions, and more.

Sign-up now

Are you a teacher educator or academic, a practitioner, or a policy advisor, who is keen to keep up with ECE research?

Maybe you are planning to do some research yourself? Or maybe you are advising and supervising students who are undertaking projects?

Enjoy unrestricted access to the hundreds of articles in the Research Area of our OECE website.

Choose your own username and password when you subscribe online. This will be your login for access.

Libraries can request IP address access for staff and students on the library site, instead of password access.  Please note that this is dependent on whether system settings at your end can support this.

Your investment

Personal research user membership – $79.00 for 12-months

Libraries and tertiary education institutions – $250.00 for 12-months

Please see and abide by the Terms & Conditions of membership.

Article copyright belongs to the OECE / ChildForum. You are welcome to add a link to this research article on your website.

Related Posts

teacher wages, pay scales, in childcare and early childhood education

What ECE Teachers and Workers Earn: Pay, Benefits and Conditions

Anyone thinking about getting a job in ECE working in ECE or thinking about moving to a different service will find clear, practical information in this article about pay rates, employment conditions, and what to expect in different roles. It explains everything from starting salaries and pay‑step calculations to workplace rights, benefits, and how to recognise a supportive, professional environment.

Read More »
children writing drawing homebased

Half of ECE services rated “below the threshold for quality” by Education Review Office on at least one metric in the last year

OPINION/ANALYSIS – October 23, 2025

The Education Review Office considers more than half of 394 early childhood services it has visited in the last year to be “below the threshold for quality” on at least one of its four metrics.

In September 2024, ERO started using a new rating system for its quality assurance reports for ECE.

How did your service do? View our our interactive table and read full details.

The Office of Early Childhood Education’s chief advisor Dr Sarah Alexander says because ERO gives ECE services four weeks’ notice of reviews, it was concerning that so many services were still not measuring up to quality standards.

Moreover, because the Education Review Office no longer has the capacity or resources to review every licensed service it now assesses only a small selection from providers that operate 14 or more services. As a result, we have no way of knowing how many of these services fall below ERO’s threshold for quality.

This is a member/subscriber only post. To access it, please see the message below for details on access and joining.

Read More »
ECE Services staff immunisation and vaccination

How to do a Press Release Right

Education Press Release.

If you are planning to invite a local reporter along to your event or send an education press release out to manage what the media reports about something that has happened at your service, it pays to do a bit of planning beforehand to increase your chances of success.

Here are some tips to get you started on the ri

This is a member/subscriber only post. To access it, please see the message below for details on access and joining.

Read More »

Are you teaching and caring for children or studying for an ECE qualification?

If you are, that’s great!   Join us now, and become a teacher member.

The Office of ECE

Share This Information

Notice for Students and Library Users
You are able to access all Journal Research articles under the library's subscription. But unless you hold a personal membership you are missing out on a whole lot of valuable teaching and policy articles and other important information. At home, or on your mobile device that is not linked to your institution or library's internet or subscription - click on the JOIN button below.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

The Office of ECE Login

Take Action!

Help spread this vital ECE information, join our free social and email groups and become a member of OECE.

pay parity funding policy

1. Share This Information

2. Follow Our Social Pages

3. Get Regular Updates

Sign up to our free newsletters.

4. Become a Member