Opens in a new tab

Bungle Over new Te Whāriki Curriculum

Search Newsroom Posts
Te Whāriki

April 12, 2017.

A new early childhood curriculum replacing the current ‘Te Whāriki’ document has been published on the Ministry of Education website. It was without prior announcement until its release today and near the eve of the long Easter weekend and the start of term break.

The curriculum’s draft revision faced strong criticism from many in the sector regarding content and presentation, and the Federation of Rudolf Steiner Schools sought legal advice and wrote to the Minister claiming that the consultation process breached statutory and legal requirements.

Dr Sarah Alexander says that the final copy is significantly better than the draft, the Ministry having obviously put in a large effort to get things right.

te whariki  2017 news release

“However, there remain some major deficiencies that could have also been put right had the Ministry done more work on this.

“Many teachers were expressing a lack of ownership and sense of disempowerment owing to the way the Ministry consulted the sector over a draft revision and the short time frame just before Christmas,” says Dr Alexander.

Teachers were not given an opportunity to view and give feedback on another iteration of the draft following the pre-Christmas-rushed consultation to make sure it is the best it can be before the final copy was published today.

The lack of consultation and engagement in discussions with parents throughout NZ has also been disappointing given that children are not participating in formal compulsory education.

“The curricula of other countries were not reviewed and drawn on to make use of international knowledge and experience since it was first written 20 years ago. It also does not appear that the final document has had any independent international expert review, which is unfortunate”, says Dr Alexander.

Dr Helen Hedges, a writer contracted by the Ministry to re-write the curriculum, commented in a blog on the short time frame for revision saying, “I was honoured to be selected to be part of the writing team to update and revise the document – in an impossibly short time frame.”

In a video celebrating 20 Years of Te Whāriki, Professor Helen May, a lead writer of the original curriculum emphasised that curriculum should not be prescriptive.

“From the start, we had a vision of a fully qualified early childhood workforce. We did not put this in Te Whāriki but we did pitch it at a level that assumed teachers would have theoretical knowledge, the cultural knowledge, and the professional judgment, to weave the curriculum with their whanau, with the children, with their colleagues.”

Dr Alexander warns that by the Ministry adopting the word ‘kaiako’ and defining it in a footnote explicitly as encompassing all qualified and unqualified teachers, instead of defining kaiako as teacher and leaving it at that, the path has been laid for the de-professionalism of early childhood teaching.

In the new Te Whāriki document, the Ministry also states:

“Although ECE services use a range of different terms, this document uses kaiako because it conveys the reciprocal nature of teaching and learning.”

Dr Alexander says that this may leave early childhood teachers wondering about the purpose of becoming qualified and retaining their certification and why they are referred to as ‘kaiako’ when all school teachers are not and teaching and learning is also reciprocal at school level.

According to Prof May, the original Te Whāriki was not designed to be a curriculum that told teachers what to do. At the time one large childcare chain operator even advised the writers they should “just make it easy for my girls so they’ll know what to do on Monday”.

The new Te Whāriki had been designed more towards telling teachers what to do and it outlines evidence to be collected on children’s learning and states what children must demonstrate to show they have achieved learning outcomes.

“There is now a real possibility of movement towards checklist teaching,” says Dr Alexander.

“Our young children must be able to have an unpressured early childhood with rich learning experiences and play. This is probably not the path that most parents and teachers would want to see New Zealand early childcare and education services take.”

Already subscribed?
Login
ECE Newsroom

NZ’s own specialist ECE newsroom. 
Access national and local stories, in-depth analysis, & original commentaries.  

Subscribe Now
Membership Support for Teachers & Educators

(Comes with free Newsroom and Research access)

Become a Teacher Member
Membership Support for ECE Service Owners, Managers, & Community Organisations

(Comes with free Newsroom and Research access)

Become a Service Provider Member
Researchers & Tertiary Education Libraries

Full access to over 25 years of ECE academic research articles – NZIRECE Journal.
Plus, guidance and resources on doing and publishing research

Sign-up to a Research membership plan

Has this been useful?  Give us your feedback.

You are welcome to add a link to this page on your website. Copyright belongs to the OECE so please do not copy any content without our written permission.

Information provided is of a general nature. It is provided ‘as is’, and we accept no liability for its accuracy or completeness. See our Terms and Conditions.

Related Posts

Lead advocate and advisor on why Pay Parity for all ECE teachers is vital (image: The petition presentation for the House of Representatives)

Data indicates pay parity is not causing education and care centres to close

After RNZ revealed last Friday that the Government intends to axe the pay parity scheme for education and care teachers, in part to give providers…
school bags

Licensing Changes for New ECE Services – The Introduction of Network Management

The handbrake is finally going to go on the establishment of new centres and home-based networks from Feb 1, 2023. Anyone wanting to start an…
Toddler competently faces an outdoor physical challenge at an early childhood centre

Students Take Gamble on Recognition of Early Childhood Qualification

October 14, 2016. All students are able to have confidence in their initial teacher education provider and know that when they graduate their early childhood…
Election promises, political parties and politics of early childhood education in NZ

What’s in Budget 2021 for ECE?

May 20, 2021. Budget 2021 provided more funding for early childhood education. a 1.2 percent cost adjustment to all funding rates.  The 1.2% increase will…
number of early childhood services issued a provisional licence in NZ

Services Not Meeting Regulation Requirements in 2019

Regulation Breaches 2019 Update. 26/02/2020:  The Ministry of Education notified that it had made error in recording a service as having a licence that was…
Vaccination immunisation of children and educators teachers

Vaccination – Should it be Compulsory for Children in ECE?

Compulsory Vaccinations for Children? March 14, 2017. By Dr Sarah Alexander. Children who are not immunised are to be banned from attending early childhood education…
Young toddler with infant looking on, builds a tower of square blocks as tall as herself.

The top funded ECE services – What this says about the funding system and supporting parent choice

The top funded ECE services Should the government want to champion high-quality ECE provision and diversity of models and choices for parents, it will want…
Right of entry and visitors to an early childhood centre

China-NZ Relations in Early Childhood Education

February 21, 2019. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern is playing down any suggestions New Zealand's diplomatic relationship with China is on the rocks. The number of…
Young toddler with infant looking on, builds a tower of square blocks as tall as herself.

New Early Childhood Service Openings Surge – But What Does This Growth Really Mean

New ECE services are opening at pace across Aotearoa - but the story behind the growth is far more complex than the headline suggests. Login…
Free Kindergarten in NZ and Kindergarten teacher

Free Kindergarten Teachers Mark 24 Years of Pay Parity with School Teachers

Today marks 24 years since free kindergarten teachers achieved pay parity with primary school teachers, a milestone that remains one of the most significant achievements…
The Office of ECE

Share This Information

Press Enter to see every result.

The Office of ECE Login

Take Action!

Help spread this vital ECE information, join our free social and email groups and become a member of OECE.

pay parity funding policy

1. Share This Information

2. Follow Our Social Pages

3. Get Regular Updates

Sign up to our free newsletters.

4. Become a Member

Membership Options