“A Few Good Men or a Few Too Many?”

Search Entire Website
early childhood teacher with infants

The Original Massey University Research Study of Male Teachers (1997)

“A Few Good Men or a Few Too Many? A study of Male Teachers” by Dr Sarah Alexander was the very first – and original – research report on men in early childcare and education in New Zealand.  

The research report resulted in media and public attention to the difficulties that men were experiencing in working in early education and it showed the adverse effects of public fear about child abuse on men’s participation in the sector.

The report presents the findings of an exploratory study of the characteristics, views and experiences men and their colleagues at 20 early childhood centres in NZ. Twenty men and their female co-workers working at 10 kindergartens and 10 childcare centres were interviewed. 

The results showed that in most respects the backgrounds and training of the male and female teachers were similar. A key difference was that male teachers tended to be the main income earners in their household whereas for female teachers early childhood teaching provided a second household income.  The majority of men entered the profession as a result of unemployment or redundancy.  For the men early childhood teaching was a second career choice after they had tried other more traditional options.

The main reasons given by the male and female teachers for male under-representation in early childhood teaching were:

  • Fear of child sex abuse,
  • Low wages,
  • The perceived feminine nature of the work,
  • Low social status of the professions,
  • A lack of career structure, and 
  • Public perception that men who work with children must be either homosexual or not real men.

Male teachers had a tougher time than their female counterparts. Their own families and friends tended to be less supportive of their decision to become teachers.  They were more likely to have difficulty in gaining employment, and they experienced greater levels of suspicion from employers and parents.  Male teachers tended to feel isolated at times because their colleagues were women.

All male teachers viewed their participation in early childhood teaching as valuable for helping children to see that men can care and teach young children. It increased awareness of sexism in the curriculum and in (female) teacher expectations. Female teachers liked having male colleagues on the teaching staff and there were few reported issues.

Read the full report: Study of Male Teachers – A Few Good Men

Has this been useful?  Give us your feedback.

You are welcome to add a link to this page on your website. Copyright belongs to the OECE so please do not copy any content without our written permission.

Information provided is of a general nature. It is provided ‘as is’, and we accept no liability for its accuracy or completeness. See our Terms and Conditions.

Related Posts

many colours of paint concept for early childhood sector groups and early childhood education system

Who is Who in our Sector

Early Childhood Education System. The Stakeholders and Key Organisations Peak Bodies / Largest ECE Service Operators Operators of more than 400 licensed services in our

Read More »
the importance of touch as part of caregiving and teaching children

Owner Worried about Putting Service at Risk By Employing Men

“I have nothing against employing men – but why put my centre at risk? Parents don’t want a male tending to their child’s personal needs. This is the type of society we now live in.”   owner of an early childhood […]

Read More »
children playing with dress-ups/ costumes in home-based ECE

The Importance of a Play Based Approach

The Play Based Approach – Helping young learners to flourish. The one thing every parent, caregiver and educator wishes most for a young child is to have a happy and fulfilled childhood. What is a Play Based Approach? A play-based approach is […]

To access this member only information, you must purchase Educator Membership.

Read More »
early childhood research journal online

Children’s Participation in Disaster Risk Reduction as Curriculum

Children’s Participation in Disaster Risk Reduction as Curriculum. Dian Fikriani* and Jane Bone** * Gadjah Mada University Indonesia. **Monash University Australia. Full Reference: Fikriani, D. & Bone, J. (2014). Children’s participation in disaster risk reduction as curriculum. NZ Research in […]

Read More »
The Office of ECE

Share This Information

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

The Office of ECE Login